Monday, January 21, 2008

Ice vs the Volcano

Looks like there is an actually, you know, plausible reason for Antarctic ice sheets to melt (h/t Instapundit):

Another factor might be contributing to the thinning of some of the Antarctica's glaciers: volcanoes.

In an article published Sunday on the Web site of the journal Nature Geoscience, Hugh Corr and David Vaughan of the British Antarctic Survey report the identification of a layer of volcanic ash and glass shards frozen within an ice sheet in western Antarctica.

"This is the first time we have seen a volcano beneath the ice sheet punch a hole through the ice sheet" in Antarctica, Vaughan said.

Volcanic heat could still be melting ice to water and contributing to thinning and speeding up of the Pine Island glacier, which passes nearby, but Vaughan said he doubted that it could be affecting other glaciers in western Antarctica, which have also thinned in recent years. Most glaciologists, including Vaughan, say that warmer ocean water is the primary cause of thinning.

Volcanically, Antarctica is a fairly quiet place. But sometime around 325 B.C., the researchers said, a hidden and still active volcano erupted, puncturing several hundred yards of ice above it. Ash and shards from the volcano carried through the air and settled onto the surrounding landscape. That layer is now out of sight, hidden beneath the snows that fell during the next 2,300 years.

Of course, if you would only listen to those with political skin in the game, volcanism could not possibly have anything to do with active volcanoes, instead being 100% the fault of 1) greenhouse gases, or 2) George W. Bush.

But given the preponderance of volcanoes across our planet, and the seismic history of Antarctica, it was bound to be determined that some of the ice cap melting on our southern continent had to do with volcanic activity. And quite frankly, a large volcanic eruption in Antarctica melting away a significant piece of the ice cap seems like a more plausible outcome and eventual cause for global warming that the current "consensus" scientific opinion has turned out so far.

Of course, you can't raise money by blaming it on a volcano...

Labels: ,

1 Comments:

Blogger DJ said...

This argument seems rather weak. A magma chamber would be located miles and miles below the earth's surface. I think the best example of the effect of vulcansim relative to glaciers is Iceland. Iceland still has its mountain glaciers despite continual eruptions.

I can buy localize melting due to vulcanism, but not on a regional or global scale. In fact, look up the effect of Tambora and the "Year without a Summer". You will see the overall impact of that volcanic event was temporary (on the order of a few years) global cooling.

7:46 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home

Site Feed